Integrating Indigenous and Western Knowledge to Transform Learning and Discovery in the Geosciences
1649338
Integrating Indigenous and Western Knowledge to Transform Learning and Discovery in the Geosciences, uses the principles of collective impact (CI) to create new partnerships between tribal communities and STEM institutions that promote the participation and inclusion of Native American (NA) scientists in the geosciences. Our proposed program partners the Rising Voices: Collaborative Science for Climate Solutions (Rising Voices) member tribal colleges and communities with Haskell Indian Nations University, NCAR, Biosphere 2 (B2), and UCAR’s SOARS internship and GLOBE citizen science programs. Together, we commit to greater integration of indigenous and "traditional western" knowledge into collectively-developed climate change research projects, enhancing our collective ability to address climate change, and contributing to climate resilience in all communities. In doing so, this partnership provides pathways for Native American students from middle school through college, to grad school and beyond, by connecting citizen science programs for Native American middle and high school students with real-world summer research internship experiences for undergraduates and graduate students that address topics of mutual interest across tribal communities, tribal college faculty, traditional science institutions, and community-based citizen science. As part of this effort, our partners commit to providing professional development for NCAR and Biosphere 2 scientists on how to engage appropriately with tribal communities and the wealth of knowledge they bring, and create welcoming and open environments within "traditional western" science institutions for indigenous scientists and communities.
Barbara Rogoff
UCSC Foundation Distinguished Professor of Psychology
Wow! This project is so timely and important! Especially in light of research indicating that for Native youth in many North American communities, wellbeing is enhanced by connecting with traditional Indigenous Knowledge Systems.
Barbara Rogoff
UCSC Foundation Distinguished Professor of Psychology
Are you collecting information on the youths' sense of agency and wellbeing in addition to their academic involvement?
Carolyn Brinkworth
Absolutely - an important component is looking at how welcome the youth feel in science (and whether our mentor training increased their feelings of inclusiveness), and seeing how the program affects their science identity.
Joni Falk
I appreciate how you describe interventions along the pathway for middle school all the way to graduate school. Carolyn, you speak about how the NSF Includes project builds on work started by the Rising Voices Collective. What new element or focus will the NSF INCLUDES grant allow you to do? How are you envision "success" and how will you be able to measure it?
Thanks for this really interesting video.
Carolyn Brinkworth
The NSF INCLUDES grant offers us a great opportunity to involve students in the research projects. Rising Voices has been a vital venue for crucial discussions between "western" scientists and indigenous communities, and this grant puts money behind really getting research projects going, involving students in work that allows them pathways back to their home communities should they choose, and brings in the additional mentor training component for our "western" scientists to ensure that they're creating welcoming environments for their Native American partners and students. It also allows us to reach younger students who really weren't being reached consistently by RV. RV really is an incredible program, and we're really happy that this grant is allowing us to add some additional structure and pathways to the work already being done.
Carolyn Brinkworth
Measurement of success is five-fold:
1) Increase in research collaborations and published papers that integrate indigenous and western/mainstream knowledge
2) Persistence of Native American students in the sciences and into grad school
3) Increasing in feelings of belonging for Native American students, scientists, and communities in the research environment, as measured by surveys asking about inclusion, respect, and feelings of belonging, and intent to persist
4) Increase in science identity in the middle and high school students, and intent to remain in science
5) Development of good practices for other institutions wishing to develop similar relationships.
I'd also add that we really hope to affect mainstream scientists' attitudes about what the value of science looks like, and how we can do far better science when we bring in a diversity of thought and ways of knowing.
Barbara Rogoff
UCSC Foundation Distinguished Professor of Psychology
Hi Carolyn,
These measures of success look great. Stephanie Fryberg's (Tulalip) research would also suggest that having a sense that persisting in STEM is a contribution to their community would be helpful to STEM belonging and persistence. You probably know her research; I think it connects.
Good luck, Barbara
Carolyn Brinkworth
Absolutely! Thanks for pointing this out!
Joni Falk
Thanks for the informative reply!
April Lindala
Aanii (hi) Carolyn, Your video and answers above are very informative. As you may remember, I reached out to you on Trellis a while back as I am with the Indigenous Women Working within the Sciences project. :-) From my lens, the IWWS pilot project has a distinct alignment to your program in that it is about ways of knowing and valuing diverse ways of knowing and teaching. I hope we can connect some time soon to see if there are ways we can work together. Chi miigwech (Great thanks)!
Carolyn Brinkworth
April, I'm so sorry I didn't get back to you re: your message on Trellis. Yes, let's find a time to talk. I'll drop you a PM.
Leslie Goodyear
Principal Research Scientist
Thanks for sharing your vision! What would success look like for your Launch Pilot project? In the short term? In the long term?
Daniel Wildcat
In the short-term, getting American Indian and Alaska Native students into Earth Sciences under-graduate and graduate degree programs. Long-term - getting much more robust research agendas established in the area of climate adaptation that draws on the combined use of Indigenous knowledge(s) and methodologies with classic Western scientific knowledges/methodologies in what would amount to community-based research projects. As my good friend Kalani Souza, Hawaiian Wisdom-Keeper likes to points out, "Some minds are always better than one mind."
Marjorie Zatz
This looks terrific -- I'm really excited to see how it develops. There are some nice points of connection with our CAHSI INCLUDES pilot, which focuses on Hispanic students in the computational sciences (broadly defined), from community college through grad school and beyond.
Carolyn Brinkworth
Thanks for the heads-up, Marjorie! I'll take a look at your video.
Cathy Manduca
Hi Carolyn, Dan and colleagues-
Great video. Exciting to see this work going forward. The video helps me see the connections between our projects even more clearly. EarthConnections is also in the geosciences but is starting with a focus in seismic hazards and water resources. We will also be making use of GLOBE (in Atlanta), and building on undergraduate research experiences (with IRIS and SCEC). Our Oklahoma Tribal Nations Alliance is meeting tomorrow. It seems like it would be valuable to get in touch after that meeting to learn more about how we can help each other. Oklahoma Alliance description is here: http://serc.carleton.edu/earthconnections/oklah....
Carolyn Brinkworth
Thanks Cathy!! We should definitely talk. Let's find some time in the next couple of weeks?
Cathy Manduca
Sounds great. I'll be in touch by email.
Kristin Wegner
Dear Cathy,
Great to hear about your work and connections -Thank you for your comment. I'm the GLOBE point-of-contact for this team, and I'd love to chat more with you about the use of GLOBE in Atlanta and other communities! Please feel free to email kwegner@ucar.edu. Best, Kristin
Sandra Laursen
great stuff, Carolyn, Kristin and all. I am excited about the potential to draw on observations and knowledge about climate change from people in communities where climate impacts may hit hard... but where there are also great lessons about long-term resilience. Also love the focus on youth as people who can bring both science and indigenous perspectives to the table. I don't see resilience in your list of success measures - what do you hope to learn there, and how will you track it?
Further posting is closed as the event has ended.